After you have seen Madan Mohan Lal Ji Mandir, visit this restaurant. Surti 12 Handi serves nicely cooked nihari. 4.3 is what this place got from the Google rating system.
Best Bara Handi and Nalli Nihari one can have in Mumbai. Even better than Surti's erstwhile outlet in Bori Mohalla. Definitely worth a try (even if you've had hundreds of Bara Handi before). Note: The place does not serve. Only takeaways.